Village in Waukesha County, Wisconsin. Data-backed housing guide by Kinan Sawar, MD — REALTOR® at Shorewest, REALTORS®. Figures as of 2026-07-03.
| Typical home value | $727,339 |
|---|---|
| 1-year change | +4.4% |
| 5-year change | +27.5% |
| Typical rent | not published |
The typical home in Nashotah, Wisconsin is worth about $727,339 as of 2026-07-03, up 4.4% over the past year and up 27.5% over five years. Source: Zillow Home Value Index, compiled by Sawar Homes.
Nashotah ranks fourth of 27 Waukesha County municipalities by typical home value: $727,339 as of April 30, 2026. The premium over the county median of $534,102 is $193,237, or about 36%; against the seven-county regional median of $455,834, the premium is roughly 60%.
One number stands out in Nashotah's data: the pace of the last twelve months. Values rose 4.4% in the past year, below the average annual rate implied by the five-year gain of 27.5% (roughly 5% per year compounded). The recent year ran cooler than the longer trend.
ZIP 53058 tells a consistent story — its typical value of $731,098 sits within $4,000 of the village-wide figure.
Nashotah is boxed in by higher- and lower-priced Lake Country peers on both sides. Summit ($765,778) and Delafield ($757,187) trade above it; Elm Grove ($697,367) and Hartland ($669,294) trade below. The gap from Nashotah up to Delafield is about $30,000 — around 4% — making those two markets close substitutes on price.
Five-year appreciation of 27.5% is solid, but the deceleration to 4.4% in the latest year is the trajectory note worth watching. Whether that continues is unknowable from a single data point, and past figures do not guarantee future results. Rent and yield data are not available for Nashotah in the current dataset.
| ZIP code | Typical home value | 1-year change | Typical rent |
|---|---|---|---|
| 53058 | $731,098 | +4.8% | — |
| Homes sold (arms-length, single-family) | 26 |
|---|---|
| Median sale price | $630,500 |
| Middle 50% of sales | $338,125 to $778,750 |
| Government-backed financing (FHA/VA/USDA) | 0% |
| Seller-financed | 0% |
Over the 12 months ending June 2026, 26 single-family homes sold in Nashotah, Wisconsin in arms-length transactions, at a median price of $630,500. Half of those sales fell between $338,125 and $778,750. Source: Wisconsin Department of Revenue real estate transfer returns, compiled by Sawar Homes — every recorded sale, including for-sale-by-owner and builder-direct transactions that never appear in the MLS.
Small sample: fewer than 30 recorded sales in Nashotah during this window, so these figures move a lot year to year.
Zillow’s typical-home-value estimate for Nashotah is $727,339, while homes that actually changed hands had a median price of $630,500 — a difference of -13.3%. These measure different things, and neither is wrong: the index estimates the value of every home whether or not it sold, while the sale figure reflects only the homes that changed hands, which usually skew toward the more affordable end of the market.
For buyers, the 4.4% one-year change is the most useful number on the page: among the figures available here, it suggests less recent price pressure than the five-year trend would imply. The near-identical ZIP 53058 value ($731,098 versus $727,339 village-wide) means the ZIP-level and municipal figures corroborate each other, which adds confidence when evaluating a list price against the typical value.
Sellers still hold a top-four county rank and a typical value nearly $200,000 above the Waukesha County median. Pricing should account for the softer recent pace — comps from the last year reflect 4.4% growth, not the roughly 5%-per-year average of the past five. A realistic list price grounded in current comps positions a property better than one extrapolated from the five-year run; no pricing strategy guarantees a result.
Nashotah is a small lake-country village set among the Nashotah Lakes, with the wooded 19th-century campus of Nashotah House Theological Seminary on the shoreline. Waukesha County's 400-plus-acre Nashotah Park lies just beyond the village with hiking and ski trails around Forest Lake, and Highway 16 connects quickly to Oconomowoc, Delafield, and the rest of Lake Country.
The typical home value is $727,339 as of April 30, 2026. In ZIP 53058, the figure is $731,098.
Values rose 4.4% in the year ending April 30, 2026 — positive, but below the roughly 5% annual average implied by the five-year gain of 27.5%.
4 of 27 municipalities, behind Summit ($765,778) and Delafield ($757,187) among its listed peers, and ahead of Elm Grove ($697,367) and Hartland ($669,294).
All Southeast Wisconsin area guides
Kinan Sawar, MD — REALTOR® at Shorewest, REALTORS®, serving Milwaukee and Southeast Wisconsin (Milwaukee, Waukesha, Ozaukee, Washington, Racine, Kenosha, and Walworth counties). Email: [email protected] · Phone: (618) 713-2964.
How to choose a real estate agent in Nashotah and Milwaukee — a five-question checklist
Get a free Nashotah home valuation · Contact Kinan Sawar
Home values and rents are Zillow ZHVI/ZORI estimates for the named area, as of 2026-07-03; incomes and population are U.S. Census (SAIPE, Population Estimates); migration is IRS Statistics of Income. Area-level statistical estimates for information only — not an appraisal, and not financial, legal, or tax advice.